• Latest
  • Trending
Safe ‘third country rule’ isn’t actually safe for asylum seekers

Safe ‘third country rule’ isn’t actually safe for asylum seekers

July 20, 2019
Hong Kong Police arrests Terror cell

Hong Kong Police arrests Terror cell

December 9, 2019
Hong Kong The Burning of Babylon?

Hong Kong The Burning of Babylon?

December 8, 2019
France strikes and rioting ‘will carry on until Christmas’

France strikes and rioting ‘will carry on until Christmas’

December 8, 2019
China imposes new rules on ASEAN in the South China Sea

China imposes new rules on ASEAN in the South China Sea

December 7, 2019
Hong Kong’s young protesters face years in prison

Hong Kong’s young protesters face years in prison

December 8, 2019
Hong Kong & the Black Hand

Hong Kong & the Black Hand

December 8, 2019
Britons determined to have a Merry Christmas with almost 90% planning to spend as much or more than last year despite political drama

Britons determined to have a Merry Christmas with almost 90% planning to spend as much or more than last year despite political drama

December 2, 2019
Palm oil more sustainable than rivals, says Italian think tank

Palm oil more sustainable than rivals, says Italian think tank

December 2, 2019
Jeremy Corbyn Poses a Potent Threat to Western Security

Jeremy Corbyn Poses a Potent Threat to Western Security

December 2, 2019
Fears Britain is sleepwalking into a cashless society: Tap-and-go card payments surge to £223m a day

Fears Britain is sleepwalking into a cashless society: Tap-and-go card payments surge to £223m a day

December 2, 2019
TRAVEL SAFETY Terror warning issued for Christmas markets destinations across Europe

TRAVEL SAFETY Terror warning issued for Christmas markets destinations across Europe

December 2, 2019
How to destroy the European Union

How to destroy the European Union

December 2, 2019
Wednesday, December 11, 2019
Europe Global News
No Result
View All Result
  • World News
    • United States
    • Africa
    • Asia
      • China
      • North Korea
    • Canada
    • Europe
    • Latin America
      • Mexico
    • Middle East
    • Russian Federation
    • United Kingdom
  • National Security
    • Military
    • Politics
    • Terrorism
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Science
  • Sports
    • Soccer
    • Water Sports
    • Tennis
    • Olympics
    • NHL
      • Tampa Bay Lightning
      • Nashville Predators
    • NFL
      • Tennessee Titans
      • Tampa Bay Buccaneers
      • New Orleans Saints
    • NBA
      • Orlando Magic
      • New Orleans Pelicans
    • MLB
      • Tampa Bay Rays
  • Culture
    • Art
    • Books & Literature
    • Education
    • Family
    • Health
    • History
  • Environment
    • Agriculture
    • Climate Change
    • Forests
  • Moldova
  • World News
    • United States
    • Africa
    • Asia
      • China
      • North Korea
    • Canada
    • Europe
    • Latin America
      • Mexico
    • Middle East
    • Russian Federation
    • United Kingdom
  • National Security
    • Military
    • Politics
    • Terrorism
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Science
  • Sports
    • Soccer
    • Water Sports
    • Tennis
    • Olympics
    • NHL
      • Tampa Bay Lightning
      • Nashville Predators
    • NFL
      • Tennessee Titans
      • Tampa Bay Buccaneers
      • New Orleans Saints
    • NBA
      • Orlando Magic
      • New Orleans Pelicans
    • MLB
      • Tampa Bay Rays
  • Culture
    • Art
    • Books & Literature
    • Education
    • Family
    • Health
    • History
  • Environment
    • Agriculture
    • Climate Change
    • Forests
  • Moldova
No Result
View All Result
Europe Global News
No Result
View All Result

Safe ‘third country rule’ isn’t actually safe for asylum seekers

July 20, 2019
in Europe, Featured, Migration, News, Politics, World News
0
Home Europe
Post Views: 5

 

A new rule recently went into effect that makes migrants crossing the southern border ineligible for asylum in the United States if they pass through another country on the way here. There are three exceptions to the rule:

1. Transit countries that are not parties to certain international treaties

2. Victims of human trafficking

RelatedPosts

Hong Kong The Burning of Babylon?

Tata Steel to cut up to 3,000 jobs in Europe

Will European Parliament make a genuine political force within the EU?

EU Council president Tusk praises EU unity, warns post-Brexit UK to become ‘second-rate player’

EU creates permanent force to help manage borders

3. People who have applied for asylum in a third country and been rejected

This rule aims to bar asylum claims by people fleeing El Salvador, Honduras and Guatemala who usually pass through one or more countries (at least Mexico) en route to the United States.

While people have referred to this as a “safe third country rule” and discussed it in the context of negotiations for “safe third country agreements” with Mexico and Guatemala, there is one crucial difference that has been overlooked: The new regulation does not require the transit country to be “safe.” In fact, the word “safe” does not appear in the regulation at all.

The government may be assuming that a transit country is safe simply because it is a party to an international treaty that prohibits people from being returned to a place where they risk persecution or torture, but that assumption would be totally unfounded. Safety must be ensured in practice, not just under formal obligations.

Under the UN High Commissioner for Refugees’ interpretation of safe third country rules, whether a country can be considered safe for a given person requires an individualized determination. The asylum seeker must also have a meaningful connection to the third country that makes staying there reasonable, not just pass through it. The new regulation ignores these limitations, which have been accepted by the EU and reinforced by the European Court of Human Rights.

The U.S. government claims that this new rule will prevent people who are abusing the asylum system from clogging up our immigration courts. But the rule won’t actually reduce the caseloads of overloaded judges; in fact, it may add an extra layer. Because the migrants will remain eligible for withholding of removal, a form of relief that is very similar to asylum but has a higher burden proof and protection under the Convention Against Torture, immigration judges will still have to rule on those applications.

In addition, judges will now have to determine if the person actually transited through a third country to assess eligibility for asylum. These cases will stay on their dockets, not simply disappear.

If the government is truly worried about frivolous asylum claims, the answer isn’t to send those claims to another country. Nor is it to pass a rule so broad that everyone crossing the southern border will be affected, including people coming from South American countries like Venezuela, which is currently a leading source of asylum claims, and other continents.

In recent months, a record number of African migrants fleeing the Democratic Republic of Congo, Eritrea, Somalia, and Sudan have asked for asylum at the southern border. They, too, would be barred under the new rule if they transited through a third country.

Using this transit rule to try to pressure certain countries to enter bilateral safe third country agreements with the United States turns a serious humanitarian issue into a political one, where people fleeing for their lives become mere bargaining chips.

Rules like this risk destabilizing the entire system of international protection by foisting the burden to less developed countries that are ill-equipped to handle a large volume of asylum seekers. That approach is neither equitable nor sustainable.

When the EU entered into an agreement with Turkey to remove Syrian migrants arriving in the Greece to Turkey, it, too, shifted the burden to a less developed country, but at least it paid Turkey billions of dollars and agreed to resettle one Syrian in the EU for every Syrian removed to Turkey.

The U.S. is attempting to shift the burden with no agreements in place and no responsibility to assist. It is shirking its international obligations and its promise of equal protection and justice for all.

Source: The Hill
Tags: Asylum claimsAsylum in the United StatesAsylum seekerEUForced migrationimmigrationMexicomigrantsRefugee
ShareTweetShare

Related Posts

Hong Kong Police arrests Terror cell
Asia

Hong Kong Police arrests Terror cell

December 9, 2019
Hong Kong The Burning of Babylon?
Asia

Hong Kong The Burning of Babylon?

December 8, 2019
France strikes and rioting ‘will carry on until Christmas’
Asia

France strikes and rioting ‘will carry on until Christmas’

December 8, 2019
China imposes new rules on ASEAN in the South China Sea
Asia

China imposes new rules on ASEAN in the South China Sea

December 7, 2019
Hong Kong’s young protesters face years in prison
Asia

Hong Kong’s young protesters face years in prison

December 8, 2019
Next Post
EU to send $1.6B for refugees in Turkey under deal

EU to send $1.6B for refugees in Turkey under deal

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

11 + 20 =

Translate

Popular Post

Hong Kong Police arrests Terror cell
Asia

Hong Kong Police arrests Terror cell

December 9, 2019
0

Hong Kong (8/12).  Hong Kong police arrested 11 people and seized weapons, including a semi-automatic pistol, during citywide raids on...

Read more
In desperate attempt to save Brexit deal, May heads to Europe

In desperate attempt to save Brexit deal, May heads to Europe

December 11, 2018
European media see few options in ‘Brexit poker’

European media see few options in ‘Brexit poker’

December 11, 2018
EU negotiators agree on strengthening Europe’s cybersecurity

EU negotiators agree on strengthening Europe’s cybersecurity

December 11, 2018
France and Germany are uprooting the pillars of the European Union

France and Germany are uprooting the pillars of the European Union

December 11, 2018
  • About Us
  • Creative Commons
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Contact Us

Topics

Follow Us

About Us

Europechronicler.com is part of the Europe Chronicler Media Group LLC, which delivers daily news around the globe.

© 2011 Europe Chronicler

No Result
View All Result
  • World News
    • United States
    • Africa
    • Asia
      • China
      • North Korea
    • Canada
    • Europe
    • Latin America
      • Mexico
    • Middle East
    • Russian Federation
    • United Kingdom
  • National Security
    • Military
    • Politics
    • Terrorism
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Science
  • Sports
    • Soccer
    • Water Sports
    • Tennis
    • Olympics
    • NHL
      • Tampa Bay Lightning
      • Nashville Predators
    • NFL
      • Tennessee Titans
      • Tampa Bay Buccaneers
      • New Orleans Saints
    • NBA
      • Orlando Magic
      • New Orleans Pelicans
    • MLB
      • Tampa Bay Rays
  • Culture
    • Art
    • Books & Literature
    • Education
    • Family
    • Health
    • History
  • Environment
    • Agriculture
    • Climate Change
    • Forests

© 2011 Europe Chronicler